← Major League Soccer 2016 · Sun, Mar 6, 07:00 PM UTC · ref: Villarrea Armando, USA
| 10' | ⚽ | Tommy McNamara · New York City FC |
| 14' | 🟨 | Frederic Brillant · New York City FC |
| 19' | ⚽ | Razvan Cocis · Chicago Fire |
| 29' | ⚽ | Tony Taylor · New York City FC |
| 32' | 🟨 | João Meira · Chicago Fire |
| 36' | ⚽ | Khiry Shelton · New York City FC |
| 49' | ⚽ | Kennedy Igboananike · Chicago Fire |
| 59' | 🟨 | Tony Taylor · New York City FC |
| 62' | 🟨 | Matt Polster · Chicago Fire |
| 63' | ⚽ | Mix Diskerud · New York City FC |
| 72' | ⚽ (pen) | David Accam · Chicago Fire |
from ESPN event data · goals, cards and shootout kicks
What each side looked like walking in — computed only from games before this one.
| Metric | Chicago Fire | New York City FC |
|---|---|---|
| coach days | 126.00 | 65.00 |
| congestion 21d | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| elo | 1500.00 | 1500.00 |
| state index | -0.04 | -0.04 |
| venue | Toyota Park |